Pull the thread, a history unravels - The Midwest Dilemma’s Timelines and Tragedies
November 18th, 2008 by halfoI think this album hit me somewhere around the second song, Francoise. In an eerie canvas, colored only by the scraping bow of a violin and some soft accordion, the album blossomed in my mind fully formed, a picture already painted. It’s a tundra tale of a lonely, desperate man trying to scratch out a living for his family in the frozen wasteland of an early Quebec. The plains of Eastern Canada carried few opportunities; it’s easy for any man to succumb to the destitution, falling victim to the cold wind of frontier life.
And so it goes in Midwest Dilemma’s Timelines and Tragedies. The album tells singer-songwriter Justin Lamoureux’s family history, starting with their initial journey from France to Montreal, the ship’s discomforting creaking lacing the song, fur trading their way into the U.S., down through the Midwest, where they’ve shared in the American story. In The Great Depression, the driving anxiety of the time motivates the song; pushes the character, Victoria, into leaving for greener pastures, even as the expected disastrous crescendo falls around her ears. But then the family sends its sons into war, where they march to a victory anthem.
And on through the Industrial Age the family wound its path around America’s, working on the railroad, finding love and losing it. Family members succumb to illness, but family is what keeps you going, and, like Faulkner’s Emily, their memory remains, lingering like the sound of angels. Even so, just a few generations later, a main character loses himself to alcohol, and another goes off to Viet Nam with fingers crossed.
The music reflects such tumult. “Good Samaritan,” the song about Viet Nam, is really three songs in one - a moody description of a broken man, decades after the war; a march through the jungle; and the wild behavior of the recently returned vet losing control. Sioux City is about giving up to alcohol; slide guitar and clarinet whistling through the vast open skies - nothing above, nothing ahead, until the bottle is as empty as the future.
This is an album for our times. Borne of despair, there are few lucky breaks, just the desire to push ahead, through economic woe, family tragedy, and hopelessness. But even when Lamoureux claims that the “damage is done” on the album’s closer, it’s obvious he hasn’t given up - how can one give up when there’s nowhere lower to go? It’s an insight only offered through historical analysis, through learning from the lessons of our predecessors, and carrying that knowledge into the future.







